TA-DA! This took me forever so I hope that you like it.  I  changed a bunch of the words to fit it better but if you sing it with the actual song the tune sounds the same. In case you can’t tell the song is rewrite the stars. It basically kind of is Sophie and Fitz breaking up but it leaves out the part about Fitz being mad about Alvar. Sophie is singing to Fitz and Fitz is singing to Sophie and Keefe is singing to himself somewhere no one can hear completely unaware that Sophie and Fitz are breaking up. Okay, I’ll stop rambling now. Here it is: 

Keefe: You know I want you

Keefe: It’s not a secret I try to hide

Fitz: I know you want me

Fitz: So don’t keep saying our hands are tied

Fitz: You claim it’s not in the scrolls fate is pulling you miles away 

Fitz: And out of reach from me

Keefe: But you're here in my heart so who can stop me if I decide that you're my legacy

Keefe: What if we don't rewrite the scrolls

Fitz: I think you were made to be mine

Keefe: But someone still keeps us apart

Fitz: You are the one I was meant to find

Keefe: It’s up to you

Fitz: It’s up to me

Keefe: No one can say what we get to be

Fitz: So why don’t we rewrite the scrolls

Keefe: Maybe the world could be ours

Keefe: Tonight

Sophie: You think it easy

Sophie: You think I don’t want to run to you

Sophie: But there are mountains

Sophie: And some doors that we can't walk through

Sophie: I know you’re wondering why

Sophie: Because you want us  to fit in just  perfectly within your world 

Sophie: But when you try to tell me I try and get you to see it was hopeless after all

Sophie: They won’t let us rewrite the scrolls 

Sophie: You were never meant to be mine

Sophie: The scrolls still keep us apart

Sophie: You’re not the one I was meant to find

Sophie: It’s not up to you

Sophie: And it’s not up to me

Sophie: Please just stop telling me what we should be

Sophie: We can't rewrite the scrolls

Sophie: The world can’t be ours

Sophie: Tonight

All three: All I want is to fly with you

All three: All I want is to fall with you

All three: So just give me all of you

Sophie: It’s all impossible

Fitz: Maybe it’s impossible

Keefe: It’s not impossible

Fitz: It’s impossible

Keefe: We don’t have to rewrite the scrolls

Fitz: Maybe you weren’t made to be mine

Keefe: I wish he wouldn’t keep us apart

Keefe: I know you’re the one I was meant to find

Keefe: It’s up to you

Keefe: It’s not up to me

Keefe: I’ll let you decide what we get to be

Keefe: We don’t have to rewrite the scrolls

Keefe: We could change the world to be ours

Sophie: You know I want you

Sophie: It’s not a secret I tried to hide

Sophie: But I can’t have you 

Sophie: We’re bound to break  and our hand are tied

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.