Talk:Forum/Theories/Flashback/@comment-174.0.124.84-20180904174622/@comment-174.0.124.84-20180904185708

(same person but this deserved a comment of it's own:) 6- the whole thing about alvar being the boy who dissapeared makes no sence! There was the whole build up in book four that Forkle checked every boy who was at foxfire at the time, and none of them could have been him, which is why they went to Exilium and basicaly the whole point of book four, but then Alvar did go to foxfire, right? so why didn't Mr. Forkle find him when he did his investigation? and why the asumption that the Boy was with the Neverseen? I mean, Alvar wasn't even there on his work for the neverseen, right? my understanding of it was that Alden had sent him looking for Sophie, since fitz was still to young and/or couldn't do it  by himself, but then Alvar was a double agent and reporting his findings back to the neverseen, so if he realy was the boy who disapeared, then Alden would have known that he was there, and Forkle, KNOWING that Alden had been looking for sophie at the time, could have just asked him if he had sent his son out to that location on that day! This is ether a mayjor plot hole, or Shannon Messenger has something larger going on here, and I think the next book r is going to have something to with resolving this. Or at least I hope so.